The EU’s take on Turkey’s judicial reform

I’d like to highlight an absolutely first rate posting last week by Aengus Collins. I’ve been away and so only saw it recently. In his blog, Istanbul Notes, Collins provides measured, insightful, and well-written analysis of Turkish society and politics, with a particular focus on issues of democratisation. 
Following the Turkish news closely often involves immersing oneself in the paranoid, the hysterical and – sometimes -the downright weird. Reading Collins’ blog is like taking a reality check.
Last week he looked at the European Union’s stance towards the judicial reforms enacted in the recent September 12 referendum, in light of the EU Commission’s latest progress report released earlier this month.
I’ve always found the EU’s strong support of these highly controversial changes to the top tiers of Turkey’s judiciary vaguely troubling. There is a perfectly cogent argument made by many people both here and abroad that the AKP’s true agenda was not democratisation but the consolidation of its own power.
As Collins points out, the Commission continues to view Turkish judicial reform as a matter merely of rolling back the influence of the military. But Turkey is rapidly moving beyond this old military vs civilian dynamic.
Collins writes:

Is it really credible that the only threats to judicial impartiality come from the military? In the Commission’s view, it appears that “civilian”and “impartial” are synonyms. If the military’s influence on the judiciary can be ended, the unspoken argument seems to run, then impartiality will have been achieved.

… the Commission needs to be asking a broader range of questions than it currently seems to be asking. There is more to the healthy functioning of Turkey’s judiciary than its protection from military influences. If the Commission can’t develop a framework in its progress reports to reflect this fact, then it would seem unlikely that the Commission (or the EU more broadly) will wield significant credibility (let alone sway) in the debates currently swirling around the country about the direction in which Turkey ought now to go.

You can read the whole post here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: